Choose training that fits your team and your budget

Comparing online training can be difficult when providers offer different course content, learning features, support and pricing. How do you decide which option offers the best fit for your employees?

The Online Training Selection Scorecard from eLearning Marketplace helps employers compare up to three training options using a consistent set of criteria. This editable Excel tool brings your priorities, evidence and scores together, helping you make a more informed purchasing decision.

Download the scorecard and compare your training options.

What is the scorecard’s objective?

The scorecard helps you assess how well different training options meet your organisation’s needs. It encourages you to look beyond price and course descriptions to consider learning quality, accessibility, administration and ongoing support.

By giving greater weight to the factors that matter most, you can build a clearer picture of each option’s suitability and record the evidence behind your decision.

What does it assess?

The scorecard covers six areas, with suggested weights to help you get started:

Selection criterionSuggested weightWhat to consider
Fit with roles and learning outcomes30%Does the content address employees’ responsibilities and the knowledge or skills they need?
Learning quality and assessment20%Do activities, feedback and assessments help learners understand and apply the content?
Accessibility and learner usability15%Can your employees access, navigate and use the training effectively?
Administration and reporting (LMS)15%Can you assign training, monitor progress and access the records you need?
Total cost and licence terms15%Are the full costs, access periods and renewal conditions suitable?
Support and content maintenance5%What help is available, and how is the content kept up to date?

You can adjust the weights to reflect your priorities, provided they total 100%.

What’s included?

  • Comparison of three training options in one spreadsheet.
  • Dropdown scores from 1 to 5 for each criterion.
  • Automatic weighted totals out of 100, calculated when all six scores are entered.
  • Evidence prompts to help you ask providers useful questions.
  • Editable weights to reflect your organisation’s needs.
  • Scoring guidance and instructions to support a consistent approach.
  • Space for evidence links, gaps and follow-up actions.

Who is it for?

The scorecard is designed for employers, HR teams, learning and development professionals, managers and anyone responsible for purchasing staff training.

It is particularly useful for SMEs that want a practical way to compare courses and associated learning platform arrangements before committing their budget.

How to use the scorecard

  1. Identify your training needs. Agree who needs training and what they should know or be able to do afterwards.
  2. Choose up to three options. Enter the course or provider names.
  3. Gather evidence. Request previews, sample assessments, accessibility information, reporting demonstrations and written pricing.
  4. Score each criterion. Use the 1–5 scoring guide and apply the same standards to every option.
  5. Review the results. Compare the weighted totals alongside your evidence, essential requirements and any unresolved questions.

A higher score indicates a closer fit with your chosen criteria. Always check that your preferred option meets every essential requirement before purchasing.

Frequently asked questions

How is the final score calculated?

For each criterion, the tool divides your score by five and multiplies it by the criterion’s percentage weight. These contributions are added to produce a total out of 100.

For example, a score of four out of five for a criterion weighted at 30% contributes 24 points to the total.

What do the scores from 1 to 5 mean?

Use the following guide consistently:

  • 1 – Poor: Does not meet the requirement.
  • 2 – Limited: Meets some aspects, with significant gaps.
  • 3 – Adequate: Meets the main requirement.
  • 4 – Good: Meets it well, with minor gaps.
  • 5 – Excellent: Fully meets it, with strong evidence.

Can I change the suggested weights?

Yes. Adjust the weights before comparing options to reflect your organisation’s priorities. They must total 100%, and you should use the same weights for every option in the comparison.

What if I don’t have enough information to score a criterion?

Leave it blank and request further evidence from the provider. The final total remains blank until all six criteria have been scored.

Can I use it if we already have an LMS?

Yes. For the administration and reporting criterion, assess how the training works with your existing LMS. Ask about compatibility, completion tracking, assessment results and any additional charges.

Can it compare courses from the same provider?

Yes. You can compare different courses from one provider, courses from several providers, or packages that include training and platform access. Define what each option includes so the comparison is fair.

Does the highest score automatically identify the best choice?

The total supports your decision, but you should also review essential requirements and evidence gaps. For example, a high overall score should not outweigh an accessibility barrier that prevents an employee from using the training.

Is the scorecard an online assessment?

It is a downloadable Excel spreadsheet that you complete using evidence gathered during your selection process. The spreadsheet calculates the weighted scores automatically.

Make your next training purchase with greater confidence

Give your team’s needs a clear place in your purchasing decision. Use the eLearning Marketplace Online Training Selection Scorecard to compare options, identify unanswered questions and document why your chosen training is the right fit.

Resource Download

I agree to the terms of the file download(Required)
I am happy for eLearning Marketplace to store the details I have provided for the purpose of sending me the eLearning Marketplace newsletter with L&D articles, best practice guidance, promotions and news on their growing content catalogue and services. eLearning Marketplace guarantees not to sell or pass on my details and I can unsubscribe at any time.

Keep up to date with what’s happening in the world of education, training and skills. Receive details of offers and newly launched courses, and tips on effective online and blended learning practise by signing up to our monthly newsletter. We guarantee not to sell or pass on your details and you can unsubscribe at any time.